Huzzah! Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Cask Proof was named the Editor's Choice, 9.0/8.9 points and the highest rated whiskey in the premier issue of American Whiskey magazine!  A highlight from the review by Rob Allanson:

9.0 Points.
Palate:  Big sweetness, vanilla and toffee, caramel coated apples. Snickers bars in liquid form, peanut, caramel and milk chocolate. The savory edge of dusty books.
Comments:  Just what you want from a rye - spice punch, tannins and a dusty sweetness.

Get your copy of the magazine, here.  Read the review, here.